Discover the ultimate guide to Stripe vs. Square vs. PayPal. Learn the key differences, pros and cons, and find out which payment processor is the best fit for your business, whether you're a small business, e-commerce site, or growing enterprise.
20
minutes read
author
Michael Seaman
In the world of payment processing, three platforms reign supreme: Stripe, Square, and PayPal. Each offers distinct advantages based on your business's needs, whether you're running a small boutique or a scaling tech startup. While they share certain features like user-friendly interfaces and support for both online and in-person transactions, the key differences between these platforms are what will ultimately determine which is best for your business.
At Swipesum, we’re passionate about finding the best payment solution for every business. Whether you’re considering Stripe, Square, PayPal, or even a traditional processor with a gateway and merchant account, this guide will help you make the best choice.
At Swipesum, we’re passionate about finding the best payments solution for each unique business, whether it’s Square, Stripe, or PayPal. We’ve created this quick reference guide to three of the most popular payment services providers out there. Book your free consultation to learn more.
Shared Features: Why Stripe, Square, and PayPal Are Top Choices
Before diving into the differences, it’s important to recognize that all three platforms are popular for a reason. They share several key qualities that make them excellent options for many businesses:
User-Friendly Interfaces: Each of these platforms is designed to be intuitive, ensuring that merchants can get up and running quickly.
Accept Multiple Payment Methods: Whether it's debit, credit, or digital wallets like Apple Pay, these platforms cover a wide range of customer preferences.
Simplified Merchant Experience: These platforms handle the heavy lifting—whether it's integrating with your website or providing hardware for in-person transactions—so you can focus on running your business.
However, when making the decision between Stripe vs. Square, PayPal vs. Stripe, or Square vs. PayPal, it’s essential to dig deeper into the features that best align with your business goals.
Stripe vs. Square: Which is Best for Scaling Tech Businesses?
In 2023, Stripe raised $6.5 billion in a funding round, bringing its valuation down to $50 billion from a previous high of $95 billion. The raise was primarily aimed at providing liquidity to employees and addressing tax obligations rather than funding new growth initiatives.
Strengths of Stripe
Stripe is known for its developer-first platform, making it a favorite among tech startups, SaaS companies, and enterprises. Stripe’s flexibility allows for deep API integration, making it ideal for businesses with complex payment needs.
Global Reach: Stripe supports over 135 currencies and numerous payment methods, including 3D Secure for fraud prevention.
Advanced Customization: Stripe's API is highly customizable, allowing for complex, tailored checkout experiences.
Developer-Centric: Stripe’s tools are designed to grow with your business, with an emphasis on scalability for businesses aiming for global expansion.
Stripe is perfect for:
Tech companies and marketplaces (e.g., Shopify, DoorDash).
Subscription businesses that require automated billing.
Strengths of Square
Square excels in providing small to medium-sized businesses with an all-in-one solution for accepting payments, particularly for in-person transactions. Its hardware and POS systems make it the best choice for businesses looking for convenience and simplicity.
Comprehensive POS System: Square combines hardware and software to offer a seamless solution for in-person sales.
Square Banking: In addition to payments, Square offers tools for business banking, loans, and payroll.
Quick Setup: Merchants can buy a Square reader and start accepting payments within hours.
Square is ideal for:
Brick-and-mortar businesses, like retail stores, restaurants, and salons.
Small businesses looking for a quick and simple solution with minimal setup.
In 2024, Square (Block, Inc.) made headlines with the continued integration of Afterpay, further expanding its Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) offerings across its ecosystem, enhancing merchant and consumer capabilities. Additionally, Square expanded its Square for Restaurants and Square Banking services, providing more robust financial and business management tools for small and medium-sized businesses.
Who Should Choose Which?
For Scaling Tech Companies: Choose Stripe. Its flexibility and robust API make it ideal for tech-driven businesses with global aspirations.
For Small Businesses: Choose Square for its ease of use, simple setup, and integrated business tools for in-person transactions.
Stripe vs. PayPal: The Battle of E-Commerce Giants
Strengths of Stripe
When it comes to scaling e-commerce businesses, Stripe’s infrastructure offers advanced tools for handling large transaction volumes and global customers. Stripe’s deep API integration allows for a highly customized checkout experience and seamless global expansion.
Customizable Payment Gateway: Stripe allows developers to build custom payment solutions, making it a great choice for businesses with complex needs.
Global Support: Stripe supports multiple currencies and cross-border payments, making it perfect for companies with international customers.
Advanced Fraud Prevention: Stripe Radar leverages machine learning to detect and prevent fraud.
Strengths of PayPal
PayPal is a widely recognized and trusted platform, known for its simplicity and widespread consumer adoption. It’s a great option for small to medium-sized e-commerce businesses and freelancers looking to tap into a trusted payment system.
Brand Trust: PayPal is one of the most recognized payment processors globally, which can increase consumer confidence and conversion rates.
Easy Integration: PayPal integrates easily into websites with minimal setup.
Wide Range of Payment Options: PayPal supports Venmo and One-Touch Payments, which make it easier for consumers to check out quickly and conveniently.
In Q2 2024, PayPal reported strong financial performance, with total transaction volume rising 11% to $403.9 billion and net revenue increasing 8% to $7.9 billion. The company saw significant growth in operating income (up 17%) and operating cash flow (up 863%), while Venmo contributed $73 billion in total payment volume. Notable developments include the expansion of PayPal’s Fastlane feature and plans to leverage NFC chips on Apple devices for payments in Europe.
Who Should Choose Which?
For Enterprise E-Commerce: Choose Stripe if you need customization and the ability to scale globally with advanced fraud protection.
For Freelancers and SMBs: PayPal is an excellent option for those looking for simplicity, global reach, and a platform trusted by consumers worldwide.
Square vs. PayPal: The SMB Showdown
Strengths of Square
Square is ideal for small businesses looking for an easy-to-use solution that covers both in-person and online transactions. Its integrated POS system and hardware options make it the top choice for retailers, restaurants, and service providers.
Comprehensive POS Options: From the free magstripe reader to advanced POS systems, Square offers tailored solutions for businesses of any size.
In-Person and Online Sales: Whether you run a physical store or an online shop, Square can handle all your payments seamlessly.
Strengths of PayPal
While PayPal is most often associated with online payments, it also supports in-person payments via PayPal Zettle, which competes with Square’s POS system. PayPal’s wide consumer adoption and ease of use make it a compelling choice for small businesses focused on e-commerce.
Trusted by Consumers: PayPal’s brand recognition increases customer trust, especially in e-commerce.
Flexible Payment Methods: PayPal supports PayPal Credit and Venmo, offering consumers more ways to pay.
Who Should Choose Which?
For Brick-and-Mortar Businesses: Square is your best bet, with its seamless integration of hardware, POS systems, and business tools.
For E-Commerce and Freelancers: Choose PayPal for its simplicity, consumer trust, and global reach, especially if your business is primarily online.
Leveraging Traditional Processors with Payments Consultants: The Best of Both Worlds
While Stripe, Square, and PayPal offer convenience and ease of use, traditional processors remain the best option for many businesses, particularly those with high transaction volumes or specific industry needs. Using a payments consultant like Swipesum to help set up your payment solution can provide greater flexibility and cost savings.
Advantages of Traditional Processors
Custom Pricing Models: Traditional processors typically offer interchange-plus pricing, which is more cost-effective for businesses with large transaction volumes.
3D Secure Integration: For e-commerce businesses, integrating 3D Secure (3DS2) offers additional layers of fraud protection, reducing the risk of chargebacks.
Regular Statement Audits: Payments consultants like Swipesum provide ongoing audits of merchant statements to catch hidden fees and ensure you’re getting the best rates.
Best Fit for Traditional Processors
High-Volume Merchants: Large retailers, hospitality chains, and franchises benefit most from traditional processors' lower costs and custom setups.
Businesses Requiring Fraud Protection: High-risk businesses, such as those selling luxury goods or digital products, can take advantage of 3D Secure and other advanced fraud prevention tools.
Why Work with a Payments Consultant Like Swipesum?
Ongoing Support: Regular audits ensure you’re always optimizing your payment processing and avoiding unnecessary fees.
At Swipesum, we take the complexity out of payment processing by acting as your Chief Payments Officer. Our team of experts works as an extension of your business, providing tailored payment solutions that reduce costs, optimize operations, and boost revenue. We manage everything from finding the best payment providers, negotiating rates, and handling complex payment integrations, to auditing your statements for hidden fees.
Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Payment Solution
At the end of the day, the right payment processor for your business will depend on your unique needs, industry, and growth goals. Here’s a quick recap to help guide your decision:
Choose Stripe if you’re a high-growth tech company, SaaS business, or e-commerce enterprise looking for a scalable, flexible payment solution with global reach.
Choose Square if you run a small to medium-sized business, especially in retail or service industries, and need an easy-to-use POS system.
Choose PayPal if you’re a freelancer or small business focused on e-commerce and want a trusted, simple payment solution.
Choose a Traditional Processor with a consultant like Swipesum if you need customized pricing, advanced fraud protection, or regularly audited statements to ensure cost optimization.
Ready to find the best payment solution for your business? Schedule a free consultation with Swipesum today and let our team of experts help you optimize your payments setup.
Consultations are completely free, so you've got nothing to lose — and plenty to gain. Learn how our expert team can help you find the optimal payment processing solution for your business. Schedule your free consultation today!
Michael Seaman is the co-founder and CEO of Swipesum. A veteran of the payments industry and former employee at one of the largest payments companies, Michael, along with his brother Stephen, has led Swipesum since its inception in 2016. Swipesum is committed to providing innovative payment solutions and exceptional service to its diverse clientele. In his free time, Michael enjoys traveling with his wife Kelsey and their three children, pole vaulting, and engaging in typical Midwestern dad activities.
By submitting this form you agree to receive information about Swipesum product updates via email as described in our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.
